Las Vegas shooting: Why is there no warning on Smart Traveller about travelling to the US?

We’re sorry, this feature is currently unavailable. We’re working to restore it. Please try again later.

Advertisement

This was published 6 years ago

Las Vegas shooting: Why is there no warning on Smart Traveller about travelling to the US?

By Ben Groundwater
Updated
Las Vegas.

Las Vegas.Credit: Alamy

It's been a week since a gunman opened fire on a crowd of people at a concert in Las Vegas, raining bullets on them from a distant hotel room, killing 58, injuring some 500 or so. It's a shocking event, something that has reverberated around the world.

In some ways, of course, it's even more shocking that it was not unexpected. Mass shootings happen so often in the US that many go unreported here in Australia. It's only the big ones that make the news these days.

And this is big. You'd expect some sort of travel warning, naturally. If there's a terrorist attack in Turkey, you're warned. If there's civil unrest in Myanmar, you're told to be careful. The Australian government's Smart Traveller website usually errs on the side of caution, scaring people when sometimes they don't really need to be scared. So obviously there will be a warning about travel to the USA.

And yet, there isn't. The official advice level on Smart Traveller, a week after the shooting, remains green. It's "Exercise normal safety precautions". That's as safe as it gets. It's like New Zealand.

The "latest advice" section mentions recovery efforts from Hurricane Maria in the US Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico. Nothing about a shooting. The summary of notable events in the US mostly focuses on hurricanes and travel restrictions that don't affect Australian passport holders.

Tucked towards the bottom of that summary list, in between entries on regulation Homeland Security stuff, and something about Tropical Storm Harvey in Texas, there's one short paragraph: "The United States has more violent crime than Australia, although it rarely involves tourists. Mass shootings continue to occur in public places. See 'Safety and Security'."

Cool. Wait, what? Mass shootings? In public places? Isn't that kind of a big deal? Isn't that something you'd want to emphasise a little higher up? Isn't that the kind of thing that would be setting off alarm bells the size of Big Ben if it was happening in Egypt or Colombia or somewhere like that?

Of course it would. And that doesn't mean that the US is any safer to the average tourist that those other countries. What it means is that Smart Traveller's warnings don't exist in a vacuum, they're influenced by politics, by the countries we see as our allies, and the countries we see as our enemies. Warnings are not created equal.

So you need to look at those warnings, particularly for the US, and add in your own information, your own conclusions. Is the US really a "normal safety precautions" country? Are people safe to visit a place that has regular mass shootings in public places?

Advertisement

My opinion is yes, and no. Yes, you can visit the US as a tourist right now and there is a very high chance that absolutely nothing bad will happen to you. The only guns you'll see will be emerging from singlets on Venice Beach. The only violence you'll witness will be on an ice hockey rink.

The United States is a huge country full of overwhelmingly friendly, welcoming people, the type who will love you purely because you talk kind of like a Hemsworth, who will treat you as a friend, who will show you a good time and send you on your way with a smile. That's the US I know, and it's the US so many other visitors are also familiar with.

However, it's also impossible to claim that the country is completely safe, that going there carries the same level of risk as going to New Zealand, or Fiji. While mass shootings of random people continue to occur in public places, you have to accept a slim degree of risk when you travel to the US, in the same way as you would in any other country that the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, through Smart Traveller, rates as "High degree of caution" or above.

I would never advise people not to travel to the US, in the same way I wouldn't want people to be turned off going to Thailand, or Peru, or Iran, or any other country with a rating higher than green. These are extremely rewarding and welcoming destinations, and the actual threat levels on the ground often turn out to be extremely minimal.

But you have to have a look at that green threat level and wonder. What has to happen in the US for it to change?

Do you think Smart Traveller's rating for the US is fair? Do you take government warnings into account when you travel? Are there other countries that have been unfairly categorised?

Email: b.groundwater@fairfaxmedia.com.au

Instagram: instagram.com/bengroundwater

​See also: The ultimate guide to the world's best coastal road trip

Sign up for the Traveller Deals newsletter

Get exclusive travel deals delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up now.

Most viewed on Traveller

Loading