Finance and economics | Buttonwood

The hedge-fund delusion that grips pension-fund managers

Most hedge-fund managers are not good enough, on average, to offset their high fees

HEDGE-FUND managers may be feeling quietly smug about their performance in 2017. They returned 6.5% on average, according to Hedge Fund Research, a data provider, their best year since 2013.

But those returns do not really suggest that they are masters of the investing universe. The S&P 500 index, America’s main equity benchmark, returned 21.8%, including dividends, last year. More tellingly, a portfolio split 60-40 between the S&P 500 and a mixture of government and corporate bonds (an oft-used benchmark for institutional portfolios) would have returned 14.8%. Last year was the fifth in a row when hedge funds underperformed the 60/40 split (see chart).

This article appeared in the Finance & economics section of the print edition under the headline “The hedge-fund delusion”

The new titans and how to tame them

From the January 20th 2018 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Finance and economics

Donald Trump’s trade hawk is plotting behind bars

Peter Navarro’s dark vision of the global economy could shape Trump 2

China is distorting its stockmarket by trying to prop it up

State purchases of shares are bad enough, but other measures are far more destructive


Want to avoid woke stockmarket rules? List in Texas

The Lone Star State is ready to take on New York


More from Finance and economics

Donald Trump’s trade hawk is plotting behind bars

Peter Navarro’s dark vision of the global economy could shape Trump 2

China is distorting its stockmarket by trying to prop it up

State purchases of shares are bad enough, but other measures are far more destructive


Want to avoid woke stockmarket rules? List in Texas

The Lone Star State is ready to take on New York


European banks are making heady profits in Russia

But for how much longer?

Why global GDP might be $7trn bigger than everyone thought

The discovery has perturbed Chinese officials

Should you buy expensive stocks?

A new paper suggests the answer is “yes”