Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to key eventsSkip to navigation

Brexit minister apologises to peers for saying article 50 cannot be revoked - Politics live

This article is more than 6 years old
 Updated 
Mon 20 Nov 2017 12.32 ESTFirst published on Mon 20 Nov 2017 04.11 EST
Michel Barnier, the EU’s chief Brexit negotiator, speaking on his mobile phone during a meeting of the EU general affairs council. He is briefing the EU27 on the state of the Brexit talks.
Michel Barnier, the EU’s chief Brexit negotiator, speaking on his mobile phone during a meeting of the EU general affairs council. He is briefing the EU27 on the state of the Brexit talks. Photograph: John Thys/AFP/Getty Images
Michel Barnier, the EU’s chief Brexit negotiator, speaking on his mobile phone during a meeting of the EU general affairs council. He is briefing the EU27 on the state of the Brexit talks. Photograph: John Thys/AFP/Getty Images

Live feed

Key events

Afternoon summary

  • Lord Callanan, a Brexit minister, has apologised to the House of Lords for wrongly telling peers that article 50 cannot be revoked. (See 3.34pm.)
  • The 10 cabinet ministers who sit on the EU exit and trade (strategy and negotiations) sub committee have been meeting in Downing Street to discuss increasing the UK’s financial offer to the EU. The meeting seems to be still going on.

Amsterdam will be the new location of the European Medicines Agency

Background info on the relocation of the UK-based EU agencies: https://t.co/MasW1n0Goh pic.twitter.com/KDbMvmoWRA

— EU2017EE (@EU2017EE) November 20, 2017

That’s all from me for today.

Thanks for the comments.

Sir Ivan Rogers, who was the UK’s ambassador to the EU until he resigned unexpectedly in January after falling out with Number 10, has been speaking at an NFU event today. Thomas Cole from Open Britain has some of the highlights.

Sir Ivan Rogers, speaking at NFU "Leaving #singlemarket will likely have larger impact on agricultural sector than for any other sector" @Open_Britain

— Thomas Cole (@ThomasHCole) November 20, 2017

Sir Ivan Rogers speaking at the NFU "trading on WTO terms, in a no deal scenario, would be pretty damaging for the agricultural sector...The agri sector would be the one facing the highest EU external tariffs." @Open_Britain

— Thomas Cole (@ThomasHCole) November 20, 2017

Sir Ivan Rogers, speaking at NFU "outside #customsunion even with customs co-operation would be worse than inside #customsunion.' @Open_Britain

— Thomas Cole (@ThomasHCole) November 20, 2017

Sir Ivan Rogers, speaking at NFU "The EU is not the easiest partner when it comes to agricultural trade. The agri sector not likely to be able to replicate what the sector has right now [inside the EU]." @Open_Britain

— Thomas Cole (@ThomasHCole) November 20, 2017

Sir Ivan Rogers, speaking at the NFU "On the Irish border - we all know this is an insoluble problem. You cannot have a soft border and regulatory divergence at the same time." @Open_Britain

— Thomas Cole (@ThomasHCole) November 20, 2017

Sir Ivan Rogers, speaking at the NFU, "my Australian and New Zealand counterparts, when I was still in Brussels, told me that they would focus on FTAs with the EU27 prior to going for an FTA with the UK" @Open_Britain

— Thomas Cole (@ThomasHCole) November 20, 2017

Sir Ivan Rogers, at the NFU, "A trade deal with the US will be much more on their terms than ours. The Americans will negotiate hard and they will insist on their standards." @Open_Britain

— Thomas Cole (@ThomasHCole) November 20, 2017
Boris Johnson arriving in Downing Street ahead of this afternoon’s meeting of the EU exit and trade (strategy and negotiations) cabinet sub committee. Photograph: Daniel Leal-Olivas/AFP/Getty Images

And, while we’re on the subject of Brexit and Germany, Robert Peston’s Facebook post on the Brexit bill issue is worth a read. Here’s an extract.

Second, can the EU actually accept a new offer from the UK on how much we think we owe - £40bn versus EU estimates of more than £60bn - when the most powerful country in Europe Germany is in political turmoil?

In other words, is there any point making a better divorce offer when Angela Merkel is focussed on her own political survival, and is unlikely to prioritise what for her is the irksome secondary issue of whether the UK is adequately recognising its debts?

May and her Cabinet big hitters will have a genuine debate today. And they are likely to license May and Davis to offer that £40bn or so.

But it is a potential problem that some EU governments think we should pay much more. It would be of a piece with the chaos of the Brexit talks to date if the EU says thanks and they’ll get back to us when Germany has a stable leader.

This is from the BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg.

Merkel says she prefers new elections to minority govt - if delay of months, could be huge drag on Brexit progress

— Laura Kuenssberg (@bbclaurak) November 20, 2017

Electoral Commission announced investigation into Vote Leave

The Electoral Commission has announced it is investigating whether Vote Leave broke campaign spending rules during the EU referendum. It is also investigating Darren Grimes, who received £625,000 from Vote Leave despite being a student, and Veterans for Britain, which received £100,000 from Vote Leave. Grimes and Veterans for Britain both spent money on digital marketing.

In a press statement the commission said:

The Electoral Commission has today announced it has opened an investigation to establish whether Vote Leave Limited, Mr Darren Grimes and/or Veterans for Britain breached campaign finance rules in relation to spending at the 2016 EU referendum ...

The opening of this investigation follows a review of previous assessments that the Electoral Commission conducted in February and March 2017 which, at the time, resulted in no further action being taken. Since that time, new information has come to light which, when considered alongside the information obtained previously, has given the Commission reasonable grounds to suspect an offence may have been committed.

Vote Leave, Grimes and Veterans for Britain were all “permitted participants” in the referendum, meaning they were allowed to spend money on campaigning up to a certain level.

The commission said its investigation would look at four issues.

whether or not Mr Grimes may have delivered a return that was incorrect in relation to a donation he received from Vote Leave and related campaign spending;

whether or not Veterans for Britain delivered a return that was incorrect in relation to a donation it received from Vote Leave and related campaign spending;

whether or not Vote Leave delivered a return that was incorrect in relation to campaign spending;

whether or not Vote Leave exceeded its spending limit in the referendum.

My colleague Jessica Elgot has written this up here.

The Conservative MP George Freeman has now responded to the Labour press announcement about his resignation. (See 3.57pm.) And, in doing so, he has clarified that it was not so much a matter of standing down as chairman as winding up the whole enterprise.

Labour troublemaking. I agreed with No10 in July to review the role of the Policy Board after Conference, and last week we agreed to wind up the Board in No10 and focus on my work as Chair of @ConservativePF on Party Renewal #ToryRenewal. https://t.co/XbDsUkvP4O

— George Freeman MP (@Freeman_George) November 20, 2017

For the record, this is what Labour’s Jon Trickett actually said about the “resignation”.

For a man who once said that the ‘raison d’ être’ of his role in No.10 was to face the challenge of renewal in office, his resignation speaks volumes on the current state of the Tories in government.

Jon Trickett. Photograph: Sky News

We like our live blogs at the Guardian. But even we drew the line at a live blog of the EU27 deciding at the general affairs council which countries are going to host the European Medicines Agency (EMA) and and the European Banking Authority (EBA) when they leave London after Brexit.

But, don’t worry, Politico Europe are on the case. They are covering all the drama, including the Eurovision-style voting system, in a blog here.

Jon Trickett, the shadow minister for the Cabinet Office, triggered a story alert in the press gallery at Westminster a few minutes ago by putting out a press release about the Conservative MP George Freeman resigning from his role as a policy chief at Number 10. This took journalists by surprise because no one knew he had resigned.

It turns out Trickett was referring to this line, buried in the middle of a long ConservativeHome article by Freeman that was posted online at around 7am this morning. Freeman said:

And it’s why I’ve stood down as chair of the prime minister’s policy board in Number Ten, to focus on my role as chair of the Conservative policy forum.

But Freeman was not talking about resigning today, or indeed any time recently. MailOnline’s James Tapsfield says that the prime minister’s policy board was wound up at the time of the election, and has not been revived since, and so his “resignation” appears to be a bit of a non-event.

Apparently the PM's policy board wasn't reconstituted after the election, so unclear whether he had anything to resign from

— James Tapsfield (@JamesTapsfield) November 20, 2017
George Freeman.
George Freeman. Photograph: BBC

Brexit minister apologises to peers for saying article 50 cannot be revoked

Lord Callanan, who was appointed a Brexit minister last month to replace Lady Anelay, who stood down for health reasons, has just apologised in the House of Lords for telling peers last week that article 50 could not be revoked.

Asked a week ago today to confirm that the supreme court, in the Gina Miller case, said article 50 was irrevocable, he said:

I can confirm that. It is also stated by the European commission that article 50, once invoked, is irrevocable unless there is political agreement on it.

The Labour peer Andrew Adonis said he would be reporting Callanan to the privileges committee over this because it was a false statement that Callanan was refusing to correct.

BREXIT: I have tabled Lords motion referring BREXIT minister Lord Callanan to Privileges Committee for falsely claiming Supreme Court said Art 50 notice cd not be withdrawn, & refusing to correct this. A serious breach of the Ministerial Code

— Andrew Adonis (@Andrew_Adonis) November 16, 2017

And today Callanan did apologise. In a statement to peers, he said that his statement last Monday was incorrect. That was a result of “a misunderstanding of the question”, he said.

To reiterate, for the avoidance of any doubt, the supreme court proceeded in the Miller case on the basis that article 50 would not be be revoked, but did not rule on the legal position regarding its irrevocability. It was, and remains, the government’s policy that our notification of article 50 will not be withdrawn ...

I recognise that my comments have caused confusion and I apologise to the House.

Lord Kerr, the British diplomat credited with drafting article 50, has repeated said article 50 could be reversed.

Lord Callanan.
Lord Callanan. Photograph: Parliament TV

The Conservative MP John Redwood told BBC News a few minutes ago that he did not see why the UK should have to pay any money to the EU after it left. He said:

I have not yet seen any legal base for payments other than our contributions up to the date of leaving. Bear in mind how generous that is. Because of the extra nine months delay over the court proceedings, it does mean that roughly £30bn payments will be made from the date when we decided to leave until the date when we do leave, and it gives you a long transitional period for both sides, which I think should be sufficient.

John Redwood. Photograph: BBC/BBC News

Michel Barnier is now briefing ministers from the EU 27 on the Brexit talks.

General Affairs Council (Article 50): @MichelBarnier is now briefing the EU27 ministers on the state of play of #Brexit negotiations.
Background info: https://t.co/hr4DCbNN0e

— EU Arauzo (@EU_Arauzo) November 20, 2017
Michel Barnier, left, speaks with Spain’s secretary of state for the European Union, Jorge Toledo Albinana, during a meeting of EU ministers in Brussels. Photograph: Virginia Mayo/AP

Comments (…)

Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion

Most viewed

Most viewed