201. LUDWIG VAN BEETHOVEN: Art has no limits
Can you imagine being one of Vienna’s most promising young composers, a piano virtuoso, next in line to the great Haydn and Mozart, only to discover, while in your late 20s, that you were losing your hearing? You try to keep it a secret. What would people think of a deaf composer? Surely your career would be ruined. You avoid social gatherings for two years, close yourself off to the world and retreat to the countryside to wallow in your despair. You contemplate suicide, and write a farewell letter to your brothers revealing the extent of your suffering. But you never send it. In it, you mention that there is only one thing worth living for. Your art.
“I would have put an end to my life – only art it was that withheld me, ah it seemed impossible to leave the world until I had produced all that I felt called upon me to produce, and so I endured this wretched existence.”
Well that was pretty lucky for us, because despite his misery, Ludwig van Beethoven would go on to write some of the greatest music our unworthy little ears have ever heard. He wasn’t going to let a little thing like going deaf stop him from making music! In the 10 years after that letter was written, and with his hearing gradually getting worse and worse, Beethoven composed an opera, six symphonies, four solo concerti, five string quartets, six string sonatas, seven piano sonatas, five sets of piano variations, four overtures, four trios, two sextets and 72 songs. This stage of his output, appropriately known as his ‘heroic period’ included some of his most famous works like the 5th Symphony and Moonlight Sonata.
Besides music, Beethoven’s other great love was nature. He saw them as intrinsically linked, with his music being a direct expression of nature’s beauty. His favourite pastime and source of creativity was the long, daily walks he would take in the countryside. He always carried his notebook with him, ready to write down any music that came to him, often inspired by birdsong. Unlike that show off Mozart, who could write an original concert on the spot, Beethoven’s process was a long and tortuous affair. He would constantly be scribbling down notes, have to change and revise his pieces and worked on multiple compositions at the same time over numerous years before he was satisfied.
Sure, his hearing loss, along with alcoholism and chronic stomach illness left the already grumpy Beethoven even more short-tempered, paranoid and miserable, but his saviour was always his art, which he viewed as a calling from God: “To Beethoven music was not only a manifestation of the beautiful, an art, it was akin to religion. He felt himself to be a prophet, a seer. All the misanthropy engendered by his unhappy relations with mankind, could not shake his devotion to this ideal.”
In 1824, when he was 53, and by this stage totally deaf, Beethoven completed his final masterpiece, his 9th Symphony. He was insistent that he conduct it himself at the premiere, the first time in 12 years he had performed in public, but was mainly there as a symbolic gesture (the orchestra actually followed a composer standing next to the great master). Legend goes that as the symphony ended, Beethoven was a bit off time and still conducting when the music had stopped, so an opera singer turned him around to face the rapturous audience, whom he had no idea were clapping. He received five standing ovations.
So yeah, next time you need a bit of a creative kick up the butt, remember that one of the greatest pieces of music in history was written by a deaf dude.
RELATED COMICS
Vincent Van Gogh The Blank Canvas
James Rhodes Is That Not Worth Exploring?
Neil Gaiman Make Good Art
Monument to the Muse
The Calling
Quote credits: Excerpt from Letter to Emilie M. 1812. Excerpt from Quote 54, from Beethoven: the Man and the Artist, as Revealed in his own words by Ludwig van Beethoven, Edited by Friedrich Kerst and Henry Edward Krehbiel. Published in 1905 by B.W. Huebsch
Discussion (42) ¬
Awesome stuff Gav! I feel like our society as a whole has such a focus on science now that we’re missing out a bit on the art… although I did just see a reference to STEAM instead of just STEM the other day. I think that art and science are more closely related than we give them credit!
I would say no. Because science, unlike art, is true regardless of what you believe. Art is largely just belief that the piece in question is art. If the world thinks your sculpture is just a rock, you cannot convince them otherwise.
That and science is our best chance at saving humanity from itself so we need more resources allocated in that direction.
@Ian Although Science is true regardless of what you believe, the role of Art is NOT JUST to be looked at and be recognized as art by the viewer.
The same way Science is improving the standards of living for human beings, Art has a major major role to play. It’s supposed to make people feel something. Even though Science is factual, it cannot really influence the mind of man the way Art does.
Thinking about the way things are heading on the planet, it’s not far fetched when we’ll be running out of resources. Conflicts will happen over oil, food, water. Hell, it’s happening right now too. In such a situation Science fails us. It’s the Artist’s responsibility to spread the message of love, peace and harmony in the form of music, or painting, or poetry. With such an impact that people get the message and start following the right path for the betterment of humanity.
So Science is essentially just a tool that humanity is using for its own convenience. It can be used or it can be misused (this one is pretty obvious). It can’t really save anyone on its own. The only way for humanity to save itself is by changing the way we think about the world. Only Art will be able to do that.
FYI, I’m an engineer who has grown up with a background in science but the older I’m getting the more I’m seeing the importance of art in society.
Yup: Ludwig Van said it better than I could ever have..
Love this SO MUCH
Awesome!!
Great comic Gav, but where you have “the orchestra actually followed a composer standing next to the great master” it should probably say conductor rather than composer.
imho, Music is the biggest human creation…
You are right, the limitations you see are just illusions. It’s up you to decide if you want to look pass them.
BEETHOVEN is one of the greatest composer of our time, because he only cared about the art above everything else.
This one is truly awesome and quite worth the wait. Both the comic and all that you have written below it about Beethoven. This time I happened to read your write-up before seeing the comic and maybe it helped me understand and appreciate the whole thing a lot better.
Thank you!
Good one! Inspirational… 🙂
Whenever I find myself demotivated, unsure of myself, bitching about the things that I don’t have I put myself in the shoes of Beethoven. I try to imagine how tormented he must’ve been to loose the only organ through which he could enjoy his art. I try to imagine the intensity of his love and passion. I try to imagine his devotion to his art. This humbles me. This calms me and frees me to focus on what I love.
To re-quote the great Tom Lehrer,
It’s people like that who make you realize how little you’ve accomplished. It is a sobering thought, for example, that when Mozart was my age, he had been dead for twenty three years.
It’s hard to grasp how Beethoven managed to compose his late masterpieces even though he was completely deaf. He must have heard them with his “inner ear”, but he could never actually hear them being performed. That level of genius is just amazing…
The version of the story I heard was that Beethoven had gotten it exactly right (and no mention of someone else doing the actual conducting, if that’s the right word), and had actually finished when one of the players gently turned him around so that he could see the rapturous standing ovation the audience was giving him.
As as Terry Pratchett put it in “Soul Music”:
I’VE NOTICED THAT FAMOUS COMPOSERS IN PARTICULAR HANG ON FOR A LONG TIME. DEAF AS POSTS, MOST OF THEM, WHEN I COME CALLING. I EXPECT SOME GOD SOMEWHERE FINDS THAT VERY AMUSING. Death contrived to look disdainful. IT’S THEIR KIND OF JOKE.
(footnote: And, of course, one that misfires. Deafness doesn’t prevent composers hearing the music. It prevents them hearing the distractions.)
It’s hard to grasp how Beethoven managed to compose his late masterpieces even though he was completely deaf. He must have heard them with his “inner ear”, but he could never actually hear them being performed. That level of genius is just amazing…
Beautiful! It seems that governments are turning away from educating in the arts while the populous is turning it’s collective back on science. This is a wonderful reminder.
Because art doesn’t keep society running.
Actually art has plenty of limits. The material you use, the ideas that a person grew up with and absorbed from those around them, even our own sense are a limit as we mostly construct reality based on a limited amount of sensory information.
Plus art also has the downside of failure to communicate. If people don’t “get it” then it’s a waste of time. You are trying to make something intangible tangible and something inevitably ends up lost in translation.
Beethoven may have been a music genius but that’s it. He doesn’t fully grasp the limits of humans.
Also there’s the small matter of recognizing something as art. If someone says something isn’t art, there isn’t anything you can say that would refute that. A good majority of “art” is mostly public opinion.
Art does not keep society running. Art keeps society changing.
Great Art From Great Artist
Interesting.
Great Work By Artist.
Thank you Gavin for your “LUDWIG VAN BEETHOVEN: Art has no limits” comic post
http://vuelosdelalma.blogspot.com/2013/11/kampung-inggris-pare-kediri.html
Thank you Gavin for your “LUDWIG VAN BEETHOVEN: Art has no limits” comic post
The thing with high-tech is that you always end up using scissors.
I have watched in spirit, hundreds of years, the machines grow out of Man like nails, like vast antennæ — a kind of enormous, more unconscious sub-bodyI have watched in spirit, hundreds of years, the machines grow out of Man like nails, like vast antennæ — a kind of enormous, more unconscious sub-body
Nice one!….i always get inspired and could connect with the Zen comics….Great work.
It’s hard to grasp how Beethoven managed to compose his late masterpieces even though he was completely deaf. He must have heard them with his “inner ear”, but he could never actually hear them being performed. That level of genius is just amazing…
Due to the recurrent irritation that they cause, external hemorrhoids are hard to ignore whereas the lack of overt symptoms often lead to internal hemorrhoids going undetected.
Are you sure about it? Is it ready?
Great Art From Great Artist
One of the great composers of our time!
Bethoven is my favorite artist!
Bethoven is so great! You have so much to learn from him!
Well that was pretty lucky for us, because despite his misery, Ludwig van Beethoven would go on to write some of the greatest music our unworthy little ears have ever heard. He wasn’t going to let a little thing like going deaf stop him from making music
Well that was pretty lucky for us, because despite his misery, Ludwig van Beethoven would go on to write some of the greatest music our unworthy little ears have ever heard.
Mampir ke http://www.bandarq99.net
Besides music, Beethoven’s other great love was nature. He saw them as intrinsically linked, with his music being a direct expression of nature’s beauty.
Beethoven was the great composure of all times!
The cost for futures agreements is $1.50 as well as FOREIGN EXCHANGE trade costs are charged with the bid-ask spread.
Comments are closed.