Skip to content
Whoops

State Department slaps “top secret” on 22 e-mails found on Clinton’s server

Intelligence community requested highest classification for some messages reviewed.

Sean Gallagher | 239
One of the thousands of e-mails from Hillary Clinton's personal mail server that have been publicly released by the State Department. Now, 22 have been labeled with a Top Secret or higher classification.
One of the thousands of e-mails from Hillary Clinton's personal mail server that have been publicly released by the State Department. Now, 22 have been labeled with a Top Secret or higher classification.

The State Department has declared 22 of the e-mails stored on former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's personal mail server to contain information classified as "top secret." In some cases, those e-mails were related to "special access programs"—the highest level of classification for government secrets, reserved for protected intelligence and other information kept closely protected because of its sensitivity. The State Department did not reveal whether the messages were all sent to Clinton or if she authored any of them.

Clinton has maintained that she never sent any classified information using her personal e-mail—a hosted Exchange server that initially was operated from her own home.

The messages were "upgraded at the request of the intelligence community," State Department spokesperson John Kirby told the Associated Press, indicating that they had not been marked with that level of classification initially. There is no indication whether the information was sent or received by Clinton or whether it bore any classification mark to begin with.

The classification decision was made in conjunction with the State Department's Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) process for public release of Clinton's e-mails and is not directly related to the ongoing FBI investigation of her use of her personal server. It would be unlikely that Clinton would be charged criminally for the improper handling of the classified data, as thus far the messages that have been classified or redacted were not marked as classified at the time. Other conversations have been held back because they included communication with President Obama and fall under the Presidential Records Act.

There has been some controversy over the classification of some of the e-mails, as some that have been classified, AP reports, were discussions about information already public. One conversation was about an article about CIA drone operations forwarded to Clinton. But even so, the move by the State Department to apply such high-level classification to some of the e-mails on her server casts significant doubt on Clinton's contention that she never discussed highly classified information using her personal e-mail.

Clinton and the State Department had claimed that she had retained e-mails according to government regulations on her private mail server and that nothing about how she used her personal e-mail violated the letter of government law. Ironically, some of the messages may have been more secure on Clinton's server; the State Department's own internal e-mail servers have been repeatedly hacked by attackers believed to be based in Russia, China, and Iran. But information at the level of classification applied to the 22 e-mails in question is restricted to a different network: the Joint Worldwide Intelligence Communications System (JWICS) run by the Defense Intelligence Agency.

Photo of Sean Gallagher
Sean Gallagher IT Editor Emeritus
Sean was previously Ars Technica's IT and National Security Editor, and is now a Principal Threat Researcher at SophosLabs. A former Navy officer, systems administrator, and network systems integrator with 20 years of IT journalism experience, he lives and works in Baltimore, Maryland.
239 Comments