140°

Critics Unfairly Chastise Watch Dogs for Being "Repetitive?"

One of the most common complaints from critics is the “repetition” of Watch Dogs, but why single out this open-world game?

admiralvic3623d ago

I wouldn't say Watch Dogs is being chastised for being repetitive (I mean the average on MC is 80+), but that different people expect different things from games and sometimes that goes against the nature of the game. For instance, a lot of Monster Hunter like games will get called out for the lack of monster diversity. I saw people do it for Toukiden, Ragnarok Odyssey, God Eater and Lord of Apoc, it just happens and it's understandable that some people don't want to do 30 quests and kill the same monster 8 different ways / places.

However, in this end this is all perception and not limited to how a person plays. Some people will simply look at the tasks on a fundamental level and declare the game repetitive, which again, is something you see in the MH genre a lot. On the most basic level, you load up a mission, work your way to the objective (typically killing something or finding something) on map thats probably used on like 20 - 30 missions, clear the objective, go back to the base and repeat. When you put it that way, no matter what you're actually trying to do (protect someone, kill something, finding an item), it sounds very bland and redundant. Some games handle this better by adding more dynamic elements to it (God Eater 2's Kyuubi is a great example of this), but others don't and ultimately, it really boils down to how much patience the reviewer actually has.

thekhurg3622d ago

I chastised it because the driving mechanics are horrible, which makes an entire portion of the game unbearably ridiculous. There is zero excuse for a game of this generation, or even last generation, to control that shitty while behind the wheel.

Gamefly saved me $60.

GamerDad19873622d ago

I'm not siding with the game but I wouldn't say the driving is as terrible as you make it sound tho. A little over-the-top don't ya think with your view on it?

showtimefolks3622d ago

thekhurg

i rented it from gameplay, about 2-3 hours in right now. I am having no trouble with driving, i hated driving in GTA5(GTA is my favorite series)

I love how i can drive around and hack almost anything, i am so scared that when i play GTA next it won't have that.

I love GTA and Watch Dogs is a step in the right direction, so far the story has been strong and missions have been fun. I don't like side missions, i won't be doing a lot of side missions. I play games for main story and so far that has been good

This game is no where near 10/10 like GTA5(even though i feel like it should have been 9.5 because driving still sucked)

here is where GTA sets it self apart, Houser brothers, they know how to do stories in open world games

WD is an awesome game and a fresh new IP, give it a chance

uncharted563622d ago

cars seem to have a weight on them. Driving is a mix between gta 4 and 5 so I dont get it how is it terrible. I mean just cuz u suck at it and are not putting effort into overcoming the learning curve doesn't mean its bad.

AAWELLS093622d ago (Edited 3622d ago )

Yep the driving is the worst I've ever seen in a game and the sound effects for the cars are the absolute worst too. I hate the way the car/screen shakes when you take off. You barely touch the gas and its like balls to the wall peeling out and all shaky and if you hit something in the road you pop up in the air as if your floating. Even when the devs were showing the game off they'd be crashing into everything and swerving back and forth and I could easily tell then that something wasn't right. Terrible and no amount of replies from anyone can change that no matter how its said/explained. Other than that I love the game.

starchild3622d ago

I have no problem with the driving. I can do everything I need to do and the driving system has never hampered me once I got used to it. I honestly don't understand this complaint. Most open world games have been WORSE in my experience.

bumnut3622d ago

Its drives better than test drive unlimited 2...... and that was a dedicated car racing game.

extermin8or3622d ago

Did you like gta v's driving, that was atrocious this is far better and more in line with a standard arcade racer really.

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 3622d ago
wonderfulmonkeyman3622d ago (Edited 3622d ago )

That's a well-said bubble waiting to happen, right there.

I agree with pretty much everything you've said; some people just generalize too much when judging certain aspects of games like this, and that leads to a whole lot of unfair labels for a lot of games that really do deserve a deeper look into their details before judging them.

If the driving is as bad as people are saying, though, then that's one thing they do deserve to be chastised for.

Dustinf113622d ago

Driving isn't as bad as people say.. it does, however, take a bit to get used to. The cars have weight to them, and the braking feels real. Burnouts are pretty great. The only thing I cant fall in love with is the collisions for the most part. Bright flashes and little consequences.

Not as good as GTA5, but not so far behind it either.

Xof3622d ago

No, what makes something like Monster Hunter repetitive isn't the mission-based design of the game, but the core gameplay. MH artificially creates difficulty by inflating HP values, so the boss fights are always 10+ minutes of repeating the same 15-second attack pattern, with later bosses forcing you to repeat those 10-minute borefests in other areas.

Like most problems with game media, the problem here is one of articulation--people just don't know how to describe various things. I can't comment on Watch Dogs as I haven't played it, but in general the complaint of "repetitive gameplay" (as in the case with MH and Assassins Creed 1) generally refers to monotonous game design, where the game forces players to perform the same basic action over and over again with little to no variation.

wonderfulmonkeyman3622d ago

You must be new to Monster Hunter if you didn't know that higher rank monsters not only switch up their attack patterns but also gain new attacks....
It's not as cut-and-dry as you think.

Xof3622d ago

It's exactly as cut-and-dry as I think. Changing attack patterns results in those 15-second attack patterns; if bosses didn't change things up, it'd be less than 1-second.

And another thing worth mentioning is the "crafting," which is the primary incentive for play, that makes the game even MORE monotonous as it forces players to repeat the exact same mission repeatedly to farm specific items to "advance."

I'm sorry, but if you want to defend monotonous game design, Monster Hunter is not the ideal battlefield. Even musou games change things up more.

KinjoTakemura3622d ago

This game has some of everything in it. And that is it's main problem. Watch Dogs is trying to be something different to everyone who plays it. Whether it succeeds in that attempt or not depends on how well a sequel sells. Right now, if the game has a sequel cut from the same mold as the original, I would have to pass.

toocoolgames_143622d ago

I'm sort of in the same boat...when a game tries to include EVERYTHING, it starts to feel as if it does nothing really well.

randomass1713621d ago

Man, the ghost agrees/disagrees can't decide who they want to side with...

solar3622d ago

any game should be criticized for being repetitive. WD isnt the exception.

kewlkat0073622d ago

Give me one game in every genre that is not repetitive..

MatrixxGT3622d ago

I remember people chastised AC1 for being repetative. I agree but it was a new IP trying something different. Look how that series progressed. Ubisoft could definitely take these ideas and listen to feedback to produce a sequel even better. They've done it before.

StrawberryDiesel4203622d ago

I picked it up for PS4 and like it a lot. It's very polished and I actually enjoy driving from the first person view in this game as it has an awesome depth of field view to hit and it's so awesome crashing and hitting pedestrians. I have been having fun just wandering around hacking everything and doing random side missions. I'm not sure what platform most are playing on but I almost didn't pick this up for PS4 because of the obvious troll/fanboy reviews but then I watched IGN, GameTrailers, and Gamespot reviews which made me know this game was for me. Some people just can't be objective and it's so pathetic. Most gamers are morons anyway, myself excluded of course so honestly I expect nothing less, which is why I read actual customer reviews and watched objective video reviews from reputable sites with no blatant agenda. Glad I picked it up, it's fun and I'm enjoying it more than Infamous on PS4.

tamarkovia3622d ago

Finally someone with the same opinion as me and hopefully many others this driving complaint is out of control from the 1st person perspective it is awesome and handles very well cars and better on bikes and to the people who think it's repetitive I believe there are at least 3 or 4 ways to tackle each side mission and I've barely scratched the surface of the game I'm playing it on ps4 and I am very happy from game play to graphics. Hacking a bridge and making a great escape is thrilling.

StrawberryDiesel4203621d ago

Couldn't agree more my friend, this game is getting hated on so hard I almost didn't pick it up.

D3ATH_DRIV3R_7773622d ago

After reading your comment, it definitely confirmed that i'll be buying this!

starchild3622d ago

I agree with you on every point.

It's not so much that gamers in particular are morons, it's just that a lot of people in general are morons and gamers are no exception.

The hate campaign against this game has been ridiculous.

StrawberryDiesel4203621d ago

You're right, there are lots of morons out there who enjoy ruining things for others. They get off on it and it's pathetic. The internet sucks sometimes, it has most certainly created a breeding ground for trolls.

Show all comments (50)
70°

The entire WatchDogs series is 87% off and it's not even Black Friday

If you are looking for a bargain, check out the huge discounts across the entire WatchDogs series on Steam.

Read Full Story >>
videogamer.com
200°

Watch Dogs Deserves A Remake, More Than Ever

With the world of information and technology, privacy and security growing every day, Watch Dogs deserves another chance in the spotlight, now more than ever.

RaidenBlack1005d ago

The only Ubi title that deserves a faithful remake right now is Splinter Cell 1.
All 2014+ Ubi titles are just underwhelming. Especially ones from 2016+ are just cancer.

LucasRuinedChildhood1004d ago (Edited 1004d ago )

Seriously, are we so far removed from Ubisoft actually making good games that people now praise Watch_Dogs in retrospect?

"Watch_Dogs has remained one of my favourite games of the last ten years." Jesus Christ.

HankHill1004d ago

I remember being so disappointed in Watch Dogs when I played it at release. It was alright, but I think I fell for the hype and I needed a game to play on my new PS4.

obidanshinobi1004d ago

This is what happens when mediocrity gets praised as good.
Standards are slipping across the whole entertainment industry.
What was once considering rubbish is now considered as OK, what once was OK is now being praised as good etc etc.

LamerTamer1004d ago

Everyone has their own likes. I liked it a lot myself. I played through it twice and liked the car chases and the open world with fairly decent environments and missions. It suffered from the whole downgrade thing where they showed graphics that weren't actually there. No game will appeal to everyone but it was still ambitious for it's time.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 1004d ago
gantarat1005d ago

assassin's creed 1 should get a remake.

ExBee1005d ago

For certain! AC1 was brilliant at the time but with new graphics and gameplay it would be amazing! Do you prefer old combat or new though?

RaidenBlack1004d ago

I'd say a reimagining of AC1.
I direct AC1 remake would be a bad idea. It'll need better story pacing and significant better world building.

BlaqMagiq11004d ago

Old. Let it play like how it did with AC2-Syndicate style gameplay but refine the setting and story.

Profchaos1005d ago

It would need a lot changed for it to be enjoyable again as even back in 2007 on launch we were all complaining about it's repetitive gameplay go here perform one of three side quests repeat then assassination now do it over and over until a big battle with a unforgiving checkpoint system.

BlaqMagiq11004d ago

Absolutely. It needs it. The only AC I truly didn't enjoy.

chicken_in_the_corn1004d ago

I'd prefer it didn't. Ubisoft would make it so bloated, it wouldn't be anywhere near the original

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 1004d ago
smolinsk1005d ago (Edited 1005d ago )

Absolutely, this watch dogs legion was terrible boring.

Profchaos1005d ago (Edited 1005d ago )

As a fan of the franchise legion was garbage and I regretted my purchase for the first time in the franchise the entire thing felt like an experiment in NPC behaviour and released without the writers input on what makes a good story.

I don't think I'm alone in that feeling though as wrench and Aiden are brought back and the campaign was rewritten to fit them.

I am tempted to buy the season pass to play it again with Aiden but fool me twice shame on me I'm waiting for a deep sale

camel_toad1004d ago

Agreed. Despite the annoying hipness of the characters in part 2 I thought it was a really fun game. I was extremely disappointed and surprised at how many steps back they took with Legion. You'd think it was made by an entirely different team. Or was it?

It was just so devoid of fun.

LamerTamer1004d ago

Honestly one of my biggest annoyances with Legion is that they took out the camera views for the driving. I mean the behind the car view that they stuck us with is near unplayable. I always used a first person driving view. After two releases why did they take OUT features? I don't get it.

TheSinsibleOne1005d ago

The fist watchdog game was the best by far
After that they weren't weird and annoying with that hipster stuff. Aiden was a badass.

LamerTamer1004d ago

I thought so at first too. I got used to it and it ended up being good after some play time. I just had to give it a chance.

TheEnigma3131005d ago

Remake the PoP series from xbox/ps2/gc era

RaidenBlack1004d ago

They are remaking Sands of Time.

TheEnigma3131004d ago

That's good news. Hopefully it's done right.

Show all comments (45)
290°

Inside the Driver game that died so that Watch Dogs could live

From VG247: "When cars slide, they leave tyre marks. In a game like Driver, they’re an aesthetic touch, part of the inherent cool of a handbrake turn. But those dark shadows in the road also tell a story. From tyre marks, you can determine the speed of a vehicle, when it started to skid, and its ultimate direction of travel – long after the car itself has vanished into the distance."

vallencer1069d ago

Different spellings in different parts of the world friend. Tyre is a correct way to spell it.

Pridefall1069d ago

Dunno why you got downvpted when tyre is correct in Australia.

mikefizzled11069d ago

The mystery that is En Fore Gee

neutralgamer19921069d ago

Give us driver San Francisco remastered

IGiveHugs2NakedWomen1069d ago

Why did they stop making some of the best games ever? Driver was one of them.

Gameseeker_Frampt1069d ago

Assassins Creed 2 showed Ubisoft how to make money and Far Cry 2 showed them that gamers don't like complex ideas. Now Ubisoft just turns out games that are just variations of the same thing.

WeAreLegion1069d ago

Best driving mechanics ever made. Nothing has come close.

Gardenia1069d ago

A story driven game with pure driving gameplay. I'd love to see a new Driver game or a remake of the first one.

ApocalypseShadow1069d ago

Yes. This one. A definite remake of the first without adding any ridiculous fluff. The first game had great physics and sound for its time. The start of the car in the beginning cinema I watched constantly. My father and uncles were big muscle and classic car freaks. Only thing crazy about the game was the relentless cops in the last level. Insane the way those police cars were and launched at you.

Bleemcast made it look better just like PC emulators. But would definitely take a remake.

Show all comments (15)