Casper vs. Tuft & Needle Mattress Comparison

Name: Casper Vs. Tuft and Needle Mattress - Which Memory Foam Mattress Is Best?
Uploaded: 2023-04-12
Description: On the lookout for a new bed-in-a-box mattress? The Casper and Tuft & Needle are excellent choices! Know more about the materials they’re made of, their size & price comparison, and which sleeping positions suit each bed.

•

April 19, 2023

Disclosure: By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Nerd may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.

On the lookout for a new bed-in-a-box mattress? The Casper and Tuft & Needle are excellent choices! Know more about the materials they’re made of, their size & price comparison, and which sleeping positions suit each bed. Read what others are saying in our testing methodology.

Casper vs. Tuft & Needle Overview

The Casper original mattress is made with breathable AirScape foam, contouring memory foam, and supportive base foam. The Tuft & Needle mattress has a simple two-layer design that includes buoyant T&N Adaptive foam and a sturdy foam support layer.

Casper is best for…	Tuft & Needle is best for…
Combination sleepers	Lightweight or average-weight back sleepers
Couples	Lightweight stomach sleepers
Back sleepers	Budget shoppers

Who Should Choose the Casper Mattress?

Combination sleepers: Those who change their sleeping positions throughout the night can benefit from the responsiveness of AirScape foam that sits between them and the middle layer of memory foam.
Couples: Those who want to sleep without disruptions will find the Casper a great choice since it delivers minimal motion transfer.
Back sleepers: Those who like sleeping on their backs will stay supported thanks to how well the Zoned Support layer provides tailored support to the lower back and shoulders.

Who Should Choose the Tuft & Needle Mattress?

Lightweight or average-weight back sleepers: Thanks to Tuft & Needle’s foam top layer, they are likely to sink just deeply enough for the right balance of support and cushioning.
Lightweight stomach sleepers: The density of the foams used in the Tuft & Needle keeps this type of sleepers’ hips lifted in line with their shoulders.
Budget shoppers: Priced less than $700 for a Queen size original Tuft & Needle mattress, those on a tight budget will get their hands on the Tuft & Needle without breaking the bank.

Casper vs. Tuft & Needle Video Comparison

Our mattress testers, Loren and Becca go over the similarities, differences, and who should get each between the Casper and the Tuft & Needle.

Casper vs. Tuft & Needle: Top Similarities

Motion transfer: The Casper and Tuft & Needle both keep motion transfer to a minimum, probably because of how well foam absorbs the impact of movement.
Back sleepers: Both of these beds are ideally suited to back sleepers, especially those with lightweight or average-weight body types.

Casper vs. Tuft & Needle: Top Differences

Layers: The Casper has a middle memory foam layer that’s firmer in the center third of the mattress. This keeps your hips lifted, which supports good spinal alignment. In contrast, the Tuft & Needle mattress has only two layers with uniform firmness levels.
Temperature: The Tuft & Needle is infused with ceramic gel and graphite that keep the mattress a little cooler than the Casper.
Pricing: While the pricing for these mattresses is consistent with the online mattress industry, the Casper costs up to $400 more than the Tuft & Needle.

Casper vs. Tuft & Needle: Firmness & Feel Differences

The Tuft & Needle is slightly firmer than the Casper. Here, we’ll walk you through the specific firmness & feel differences between the two mattresses.

What’s the Firmness Of the Casper and Tuft & Needle Mattresses?

The Casper and Tuft & Needle are both considered medium-firm, however, there are distinct characteristics that differentiate them. Casper’s level of firmness does a great job of providing both pressure relief and support that suits every sleeping position. While the Tuft & Needle, made with T&N Adaptive foam, is a bit more firm and gives a responsiveness that creates a “floating” effect.

What Do the Casper and Tuft & Needle Mattresses Feel Like?

The Casper’s comfort layer is an incredibly soft and responsive polyfoam that provides immediate comfort and light contouring that works well for back, stomach, and side sleepers. In contrast, the Tuft & Needle is cushioning and conforming, but it doesn’t have the hug or “sticky” feel of memory foam. With just one comfort layer, you won’t sink very deep into the Tuft & Needle but this top layer is soft enough to cradle the curves of sleepers who weigh less than 230 lbs.

What’s It Like to Sleep On the Casper and Tuft & Needle Mattresses?

While lightweight and average-weight people are well supported on the Casper Original no matter their sleeping position, heavier folks are not as good of a fit. Similarly, the Tuft & Needle is a good mattress for back sleepers under 230 lbs—lightweight and average-weight people should experience light cradling of the spine without excessive dipping at the hips.

The Casper vs. Tuft & Needle Mattresses By Body Type

Casper Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:	BACK SLEEPERS	STOMACH SLEEPERS	SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):	5	4	4
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):	5	3	5
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):	3	2	2

Tuft & Needle Performance By Body Type & Sleeping Position:

Body Type:	BACK SLEEPERS	STOMACH SLEEPERS	SIDE SLEEPERS
Lightweight (< 130 lbs):	4	4	2
Average-weight (130–230 lbs):	4	3	4
Heavyweight (> 230 lbs):	3	2	2

1 = Very poor, 2 = Not good, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent

Average-Weight Sleepers (130–230 lbs)

The Casper mattress provides excellent comfort for average-weight back sleepers and side sleepers. It keeps the hips and neck in line while also protecting pressure points such as the shoulders, hips, and lower parts of the back. Average-weight side sleepers should experience sufficient pressure relief near their hips and shoulder while laying on the Tuft & Needle. However, it might be too soft for average-weight stomach sleepers.

Heavyweight Sleepers (> 230 lbs)

Heavyweight stomach sleepers and side sleepers might not get the proper spine alignment and comfortable pressure relief they need on the Casper mattress. The Tuft & Needle is also not supportive enough for heavyweight side sleepers. If you’re a heavyweight back sleeper, the Tuft & Needle is not the best fit since you’ll get much better support on a firmer mattress with sturdier materials like innerspring coils. You can find a few of our favorite options by checking out our best mattresses for back sleepers.

Lightweight Sleepers (< 130 lbs)

Lightweight back sleepers can look forward to the Casper mattress, especially when you’re looking for one that fills in the small of your back. Combination sleepers who move around often throughout the night are a good fit for the Casper mattress. We think the Tuft & Needle is a little too firm for lightweight side sleepers who spend the majority of the night on their sides but lightweight back sleepers should experience light cradling of the spine without excessive dipping at the hips on the Tuft & Needle.

Differences In Mattress Construction

Read on to find out what the Casper and Tuft & Needle mattresses are made of.

Casper Mattress Materials	Tuft & Needle Mattress Materials
Recycled polyester	Polyester fabric
AirScape foam	T&N Adaptive foam
Zoned Support foam	High-density polyfoam
Base foam
11”	10”

Cover

Casper’s cover is made from a fabric blend that contains up to 57 recycled bottles. The fabric is soft, stretchy, breathable, and durable. The Tuft & Needle mattress is covered in soft polyester fabric that allows you to sink deeply into the top layer of Adaptive foam.

Comfort Layers

The Casper mattress is topped with AirScape foam, which is a polyfoam specially formulated to conform to the shape of your body and quickly adapt to changes in your sleeping position. Tuft & Needle’s T&N Adaptive foam is an open-cell foam, meaning there are plenty of air pockets to facilitate airflow.

Support Layers

The base of the Casper consists of a thick layer of dense polyfoam. The final layer of the Tuft & Needle is a durable and dense polyurethane foam that brings a distinct all-foam mattress feel.

Casper vs. Tuft & Needle Mattresses Pricing

Size	Casper Mattress Prices	Tuft & Needle Mattress Prices
Twin	$	$
Twin XL	$	$
Full	$	$
Queen	$	$
King	$	$
California King	$	$

For exclusive discounts on both beds see our Casper mattress coupons and Tuft & Needle mattress coupons.

Casper vs. Tuft & Needle Mattress Performance Ratings & Differences

The Casper 4.8/5

The Casper Original mattress is an all-foam bed that pairs plush polyfoam with Zoned Support memory foam for excellent pressure relief and body alignment. The Casper Original provides comfort for back, stomach, side, and combination sleepers who weigh less than 230 lbs, and its motion isolation makes it good for couples.

The Tuft & Needle 3.5/5

The original Tuft & Needle is an all-foam mattress for those who want an entry-level bed with broad appeal. The T&N is budget-friendly and has a medium-firm feel that balances cushioning and support. It’s best for back and side sleepers under 230 lbs.

Temperature

Casper and Tuft & Needle do their part to give the flagship mattresses better temperature neutrality: Casper perforates the AirScape foam, which creates hundreds of tiny channels for airflow, and Tuft & Needle infuses the Adaptive foam with cooling gel and graphite. With that said, we think the Tuft & Needle sleeps a fraction cooler than the Casper.

Motion Transfer

In this case, the Casper has better motion isolation, but the Tuft & Needle will still work for couples who don’t move around a lot at night. See the best mattresses for couples for more.

Edge Support

The Casper’s dense foam layers keep you well supported along its edges, but we noticed a little compression near the edges of the Tuft & Needle.

Pressure Relief

Even though the Tuft & Needle mattress doesn’t provide as much pressure relief, it’s still sufficient for average-weight back sleepers and lightweight stomach sleepers.

Pain Relief

The Casper Original is one of the best beds for lightweight and average-weight people with back pain. With a soft comfort layer that cushions the body and a Zoned Support transition layer, the Casper is designed to keep the spine properly supported in every sleeping position. If you have lower back pain, you need a mattress that keeps your hips elevated in line with your shoulders. The Tuft & Needle is firm and supportive enough for back sleepers with back pain under 230 lbs.

Durability

All-foam mattresses generally last seven to 10 years, and both the Casper and Tuft & Needle mattresses are protected against defects through 10-year warranties.

Shipping, Returns, & Warranties

Casper

Casper customers in the U.S. and Canada get free shipping, while those in Alaska and Hawaii are required to pay an extra shipping fee. Once your mattress is delivered, the Casper 100-night sleep trial starts. After the trial period ends, Casper mattresses are covered by a 10-year warranty that protects against manufacturing defects like indentations, cracks, splits, and broken zippers.

Tuft & Needle

When you purchase a Tuft & Needle mattress, you can have peace of mind knowing that your product will be carefully compressed and vacuum-sealed before being shipped free to your home (that is, if you live within the contiguous U.S.). Tuft & Needle offers a 100-night sleep trial period and also comes with a 10-year limited warranty.

More Tuft & Needle Mattresses

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

More Casper Mattresses

This mattress is no longer available for purchase. To help you find your next mattress, check out our list of the best mattresses available on the market now.

Haven’t decided which mattress is best for you? Check out these other comparisons:

Our Final Take

The Casper and Tuft & Needle original mattresses have similar builds, but actually feel quite different. Casper’s responsive, motion isolating top layer is best for combination sleepers and couples. The softer foam near the head of the mattress makes it a better choice for side sleepers. If you’re a lightweight back or stomach sleeper, then the Tuft & Needle may be your best bet. The T&N mattress is also a better option for budget shoppers.

Casper and Tuft & Needle Mattresses FAQs

Do Tuft & Needle mattresses soften?

The Tuft & Needle original mattress isn’t the most durable mattress on the market. We estimate it will last you around six years before the top layer begins to soften or form permanent body impressions. However, this softening may actually be to the benefit of side sleepers.

Do Casper mattresses sag?

Casper mattresses are unlikely to sag in the first seven to ten years of ownership so long as they are set atop a supportive base. Casper covers body indentations of greater than 1 inch during the 10-year warranty, so you’re covered in the case of a deep impression.

Are Casper mattresses good?

Casper is one of the most popular bed-in-a-box mattress brands with primarily positive customer reviews since they opened in 2014. They carry a wide selection of high-quality foam and hybrid models to fit the needs of diverse customers, and they back every mattress with a risk-free sleep trial.